You can never be too thin or too rich, right?
I totally agree with the second half of the statement you can never be too rich, there's no such thing. Too thin? Yip. You can definitely be too thin.
Not so for Ralph Lauren. They recently found themselves in a spot of hot water over some dodgily photoshopped images. They should have known something wasn't right when their model had a head bigger than her pelvis and a neck the size of a tooth pic. It was published anyway.
The Ralph Lauren marketing team didn't take the criticism well. Citing an "image infringement", they issued a "take down" notice to their detractors, in this case the PhotoshopDisasters blog, who bowed to legal pressure. Others weren't so accommodating and the take down order was savagely mocked, along with the picture in question, on sites all over the web.
Copyright law doesn't actually let you threaten the critics that point out your mistakes which begs the question, "Why so sensitive Ralph Lauren"
Photoshop mistakes have been going on for as long as Photoshop itself. The latest picture is strikingly similar to the Brad Pitt Edwin Jeans ad where the male half of Brangelina's head and shoulders were photoshopped totally out of proportion to his hips. Advertising and fashion thrive on impossible ideals, and Photoshop is part of that, I get that, but at times it's taken to ridiculous extremes.
The real issue here is how companies handle criticism. After a video of an employee vandalising one of their stores was posted on YouTube, ASDA fought back with a video of their own. Existing staff members called for the perpetrator to be punished and the company were praised for their quick-witted PR campaign.
Ralph Lauren are in a slightly different position but they technically could have a similar online comeback. But even with loads of Photoshop videos on YouTube showing the extent to which magazine images are altered, we'll be waiting a very long time for a high fashion institution like Ralph Lauren to publish un-touched pictures in the glossies.
Picture courtesy of mugley. Some rights reserved.
12 October 2009 by Suzanne Morrow
Suzanne is a Senior Copywriter at leading UK digital agency Dog Digital. Established in 1996, Dog Digital is one of the most experienced and accomplished teams in the digital arena. Today Dog boast a star-studded
international client portfolio and a trophy cabinet full of awards. They provide bright and innovative digital solutions that work. It's that simple.
Suzanne is a Senior Copywriter at leading UK digital agency Dog Digital. Established in 1996, Dog Digital is one of the most experienced and accomplished teams in the digital arena. Today Dog boast a star-studded international client portfolio and a trophy cabinet full of awards. They provide bright and innovative digital solutions that work. It's that simple.
Bloggers
- Alex Chapman (8)
- Alex Gillett (1)
- Alex Sass (3)
- Benjamin Ellis (17)
- Benn Achilleas (7)
- Bex Clarke (8)
- Bootlaw (1)
- Borz Farahani (1)
- Chinwag News (100)
- Chinwag Team (33)
- Chris Bradley (1)
- Ciaran (1)
- Colin O'Malley (1)
- Danielle Dalkie (4)
- Danny Bluestone (2)
- Dave Williams (2)
- David Rowden (1)
- Deirdre Molloy (16)
- Diana Gray (1)
- Diana Yeboah (3)
- Dominic Campbell (1)
- Emily Fisher (5)
- Fiona Du Vivier (1)
- Francesca Heath (38)
- Graeme Harvey (1)
- Guy Rigby (1)
- Jamie Riddell (12)
- John Horsley (5)
- Jonathan Wardle (1)
- Julia Eilon (2)
- Julian Ranger (1)
- Kay Hammond (2)
- Lauren Cotton (117)
- Lauren Macready (11)
- Luke Walker (1)
- Mellissa Norman (2)
- Nicky Swain (6)
- Nikki Barton (5)
- Phil Haslehurst (1)
- Richard Woods (4)
- Sam Michel (342)
- Sam Turner (1)
- Sarbjit Bakhshi (2)
- Scott Allison (1)
- Scott Meyer (3)
- Shannon Lee (2)
- Sherrod Dine (1)
- Simon Caine (16)
- Simon John (1)
- Suzanne Morrow (51)
- Tim Ash (1)
- Tim Butler (1)
- Tom Smith (1)
Archive
- May 2012 (12)
- April 2012 (18)
- March 2012 (10)
- February 2012 (23)
- January 2012 (13)
- December 2011 (10)
Chinwag on Twitter
Chinwag Newsletter
Updated Chinwag Profiles
- Olivia Mason - The Beans Group
- Dominika -
- Charlie Newport - fish in a bottle
- Claudia Rumdle -
- Beyond - http://www.bynd.com


Comments
Post new comment